The Influence of Different Types of Democratic Conception on the Trust Level of Political Institutions: An Analysis Based on the State of National(Regional) Development

doi:10.15936/j.cnki.1008-3758.2021.06.007

Abstract

Abstract: The difference of democratic conception and the complexity of the actual political system have caused uncertainty in the relationship between democratic conception and political legitimacy. Based on the person-context interaction theories， the influence of democratic conception on trust in political institutions may vary depending on the development patterns and processes in different countries around the world. By using the hierarchical linear model(HLM) to study the data of the sixth wave of the world values survey (WVS) from 2010 to 2014， it is found that trust in political institutions is not only affected by individual democratic conception， but also related to such macro factors as the state of national(regional) development. More importantly， the influence of individual democratic conception on the trust in political institutions is moderated by the national(regional) development status.

Key words: democratic conception; political institutional trust; the state of national (regional) development; hierarchical linear model

CLC Number:

D082

ZHENG Jianjun， ZHAO Dongdong. The Influence of Different Types of Democratic Conception on the Trust Level of Political Institutions: An Analysis Based on the State of National(Regional) Development[J]. Journal of Northeastern University(Social Science), 2021, 23(6): 47-55.

References

[1]唐斌. 政治信任的概念、特征与价值［J］. 理论月刊， 2011(8):49-52.
[2]梅立润，陶建武. 中国政治信任实证研究: 全景回顾与未来展望［J］. 社会主义研究， 2018(3):162-172.
[3]陈尧. 社会转型期政治信任结构的变化［J］. 中国浦东干部学院学报， 2009，3(4):67-69.
[4]宋少鹏，麻宝斌. 论政治信任的结构［J］. 行政与法， 2008(8):25-27.
[5]孟天广. 转型期的中国政治信任:实证测量与全貌概览［J］. 华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版)， 2014，53(2):1-10.
[6]张书维，景怀斌. 政治信任的制度——文化归因及政府合作效应［J］. 武汉大学学报(哲学社会科学版)， 2014，67(5):77-84.
[7]马得勇. 政治信任及其起源——对亚洲8个国家和地区的比较研究［J］. 经济社会体制比较， 2007(5):79-86.
[8]郑华良. 经济绩效、传统价值观与中国地方政府信任变迁［J］. 华侨大学学报(哲学社会科学版)， 2019(5):111-121.
[9]Chen D. Local Distrust and Regime Support: Sources and Effects of Political Trust in China［J］. Political Research Quarterly， 2017，70(2):314-326.
[10]池上新. 市场化、政治价值观与中国居民的政府信任［J］. 社会， 2015，35(2):166-191.
[11]肖唐镖，王欣. “民心”何以得或失——影响农民政治信任的因素分析［J］. 中国农村观察， 2011(6):75-82.
[12]王正绪. 经济社会现代化与大众民主观念在东亚社会的兴起［J］. 开放时代， 2012(10):83-106.
[13]Zhai Y. Popular Democratic Perception Matters for Political Trust in Authoritarian Regimes［J］. Politics， 2019，39(4):411-429.
[14]李辉，呼和那日松，唐敏. 民主、主观经济评价与腐败感知——基于亚洲、非洲与拉美舆情表合并数据的多层分析［J］. 经济社会体制比较， 2015(3):162-174.
[15]黄嘉文，赵静. 农村青年的基层政治信任来源: 制度还是文化?［J］. 华南理工大学学报(社会科学版)， 2019，21(5):101-111.
[16]陈天祥，周敏婷，郑佳斯. 中国乡镇政府的政治信任: 影响因素及区域差异［J］. 江苏行政学院学报， 2017(1):101-108.
[17]Hooghe M，Marien S，Oser J. Great Expectations: the Effect of Democratic Ideals on Political Trust in European Democracies［J］. Contemporary Politics， 2017，23(2):214-230.
[18]王衡. 国家认同、民主观念与政治信任——基于香港的实证研究［J］. 经济社会体制比较， 2015(3):147-161.
[19]Catterberg G，Moreno A. The Individual Bases of Political Trust: Trends in New and Established Democracies［J］. International Journal of Public Opinion Research， 2006，18(1):31-48.
[20]张文宏，马丹. 社会经济地位、民主观念与政治信任——以上海为例［J］. 江苏行政学院学报， 2015(1):52-62.
[21]You Y，Wang Z. The Internet， Political Trust， and Regime Types［J］. Japanese Journal of Political Science， 2019，21(2):68-89.
[22]van der Meer T，Hakhverdian A. Political Trust as the Evaluation of Process and Performance［J］. Political Studies， 2017，65(1):81-102.
[23]王正绪. 东亚公民对政治机构的信任:制度与文化的差异［J］. 开放时代， 2016(2):119-137.
[24]高巍. 当前中国居民政府信任的区域比较［J］. 东南大学学报(哲学社会科学版)， 2015，17(S2):99-104.
[25]吕书鹏，朱正威. 政府信任区域差异研究——基于对China Survey 2008数据的双层线性回归分析［J］. 公共行政评论， 2015，8(2):125-145.
[26]孟天广，杨明. 转型期中国县级政府的客观治理绩效与政治信任［J］. 经济社会体制比较， 2012(4):122-135.
[27]Wang Z，You Y. The Arrival of Critical Citizens: Decline of Political Trust and Shifting Public Priorities in China［J］. International Review of Sociology， 2016，26(1):105-124.
[28]李艳霞. “后物质主义”价值观与当代中国公众的政治信任［J］. 公共管理学报， 2017，14(3):60-72.
[29]Chen J，Dickson B J. Allies of the State: Democratic Support and Regime Support Among China's Private Entrepreneurs［J］. China Quarterly， 2008，19(6):780-804.
[30]Huhe N，Tang M. Contingent Instrumental and Intrinsic Support: Exploring Regime Support in Asia［J］. Political Studies， 2017，65(1):161-178.［31］Mauk M. Disentangling an Elusive Relationship: How Democratic Value Orientations Affect Political Trust in Different Regimes［J］. Political Research Quarterly， 2020，73(2):366-380.［32］张冲，万远英. 村民政治参与、民主观念与政府信任［J］. 统计与信息论坛， 2016，31(10):94-98.［33］王衡. 当我们谈论民主时，我们在谈论什么——转型期中国公众民主观念的类型学分析［J］. 探索与争鸣， 2017(10):141-148.［34］李毅明. 广西基层政府信任影响因素研究［D］. 南宁: 广西民族大学， 2013.［35］陶思佳. 社会资本、生活满意度与公众的政府评价［D］. 杭州: 浙江财经大学， 2018.［36］DiPietro W. Economic and Other Determinants of Political Trust［M］. Hershey: IGI Global， 2014:1-7.［37］Ruelens A，Meuleman B，Nicaise I. Examining Macroeconomic Determinants of Trust in Parliament［J］. Social Science Research， 2018，75:142-153.［38］Casetti M M，Gutiérrez M B，Sánchez J S. Determinants of Political Trust:a Cross-sectional Study［J］. Revista Del Clad Reforma Y Democracia， 2018，71:5-26.