政府和钢铁企业间行为策略的演化博弈分析——有机朗肯循环技术推广

doi:10.12068/j.issn.1005-3026.2022.11.018

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 为了探索合理促进钢铁企业采用有机朗肯循环(organic Rankine cycle，ORC)技术回收低温余热，建立了有关我国政府机构与钢铁企业之间的演化博弈模型，分析了演化稳定性以及关键参数对演化轨迹的影响.结果表明:实施成本和环境污染税费对ORC技术的推广是非常重要的.在政治和社会效益最大化的基础上，较高的能耗和环境污染税费更加促使政府对ORC技术推广.初始选择概率值接近或者大于临界值，对双方推动ORC技术都有利.提高监管支出以及政治和社会效益，使政府更具有积极性；增加环境污染税费、ORC发电效益和减少环境污染带来的效益，使企业更具有积极性；提高运营亏损补贴和技术补助以及技术部署成本，对政府和企业都是消极的.

关键词: ORC技术；演化博弈论；政府机构；钢铁企业

Abstract: An evolutionary game model between Chinese governments and steel works is established to explore how to reasonably promote steel works to use organic Rankine cycle(ORC)technology for recovering low-temperature waste heat， and the influences of evolutionary stability and key parameters on the evolutionary trajectory are analyzed. The results show that implementation costs and environmental pollution taxes are essential for ORC technology promotion. Charging higher taxes on energy consumption and environmental pollution can provide more incentives for governments to promote the application of ORC technology based on maximizing political and social benefits. Both parties benefit from having initial probabilities that are close to or larger than the critical value for popularizing ORC technology. Increasing regulatory expenditures， as well as political and social benefits， motivates governments; adding environmental pollution taxes， ORC generation benefits， and gains from reducing environmental pollution inspires companies; increasing operational loss subsidies and technical allowances， as well as technology deployment costs， is detrimental for both governments and companies.

Key words: ORC technology; evolutionary game theory; government agencies; steel works

中图分类号:

张朝，张欣欣. 政府和钢铁企业间行为策略的演化博弈分析——有机朗肯循环技术推广[J]. 东北大学学报（自然科学版）, 2022, 43(11): 1653-1661.

ZHANG Chao， ZHANG Xin-xin. Evolutionary Game Analysis on the Behavioral Strategies Between Governments and Steel Works: Organic Rankine Cycle Technology Promotion[J]. Journal of Northeastern University(Natural Science), 2022, 43(11): 1653-1661.

参考文献

[1]中华人民共和国工业和信息化部.钢铁工业“十二五”发展规划［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.https://www.miit.gov.cn/jgsj/ycls/ ghzc/art/2020/art_614afea56cf24 caa9eaae03bd644cea8.html.(Ministry of Industry and Information Technology of the People’s Republic of China.12th Five-Year Development Plan for iron and steel industry ［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.https://www.miit.gov.cn/jgsj/ycls/ghzc/art/2020/art_614afea56cf24caa9eaae03bd644cea8.html.)
[2]中华人民共和国工业和信息化部.关于钢铁工业节能减排的指导意见［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.https://www.miit.gov.cn/jgsj/jns/wjfb/art/2020/art_856823bf888a 46b1aabbd9d8659cefbb.html.(Ministry of Industry and Information Technology of the People’s Republic of China.Guidance on energy conservation in iron and steel industry［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.https://www.miit.gov.cn/jgsj/jns/wjfb/art/2020/art_856823bf888a46b1aabbd9d8659cefbb.html.)
[3]中国节能协会冶金工业节能专业委员会.中国钢铁工业节能低碳发展报告(2020)［R］.北京:冶金工业规划研究院，2020.(Energy Saving Committee of Metallurgical Industry of China Energy Conservation Association.Energy saving and low carbon development report of China’s iron and steel industry (2020)［R］.Beijing:China Metallurgical Industry Planning and Research Institute， 2020.)
[4]Chen Q，Gu Y，Tang Z，et al.Assessment of low-carbon iron and steel production with CO₂ recycling and utilization technologies:a case study in China ［J］.Applied Energy，2018，220:192-207.
[5]Zhang X，Bai H，Zhao X，et al.Multi-objective optimisation and fast decision-making method for working fluid selection in organic Rankine cycle with low-temperature waste heat source in industry ［J］.Energy Conversion and Management，2018，172:200-211.
[6]Tian H，Shu G，Wei H，et al.Fluids and parameters optimization for the organic Rankine cycles(ORCs)used in exhaust heat recovery of Internal Combustion Engine(ICE)［J］.Energy，2012，47(1):125-136.
[7]Moreiral L F，Arrieta F R P.Thermal and economic assessment of organic Rankine cycles for waste heat recovery in cement plants ［J］.Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews，2019，114:109315.
[8]Ardeh E A A，Loni R，Najafi G，et al.Exergy and economic assessments of solar organic Rankine cycle system with linear V-shape cavity ［J］.Energy Conversion and Management，2019，199:111997.
[9]Tchanche B F，Pétrissans M，Papadakis G.Heat resources and organic Rankine cycle machines ［J］.Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews，2014，39:1185-1199.
[10]Ahmadi A，Assad M E H，Jamali D H，et al.Applications of geothermal organic Rankine cycle for electricity production ［J］.Journal of Cleaner Production，2020，274:122950.
[11]Tchanche B F，Papadakis G，Lambrinos G，et al.Fluid selection for a low-temperature solar organic Rankine cycle ［J］.Applied Thermal Engineering，2009，29:2468-2476.
[12]Xu Z，Wang R，Yang C.Perspectives for low-temperature waste heat recovery ［J］.Energy，2019，176:1037-1043.
[13]Mahmoudi A，Fazli M，Morad M R.A recent review of waste heat recovery by Organic Rankine Cycle ［J］.Applied Thermal Engineering，2018，143:660-675.
[14]Liao Y，Xiong B，Guo H.Situation analysis of organic rankine cycle system for low-grade heat power generation in China［C］// 2011 Asia-Pacific Power and Energy Engineering Conference.Wuhan，2011:1-4.
[15]Freeman J，Hellgardt K，Markides C N.An assessment of solar-powered organic Rankine cycle systems for combined heating and power in UK domestic applications ［J］.Applied Energy，2015，138:605-620.
[16]Ji S，Zhao D，Luo R.Evolutionary game analysis on local governments and manufacturers′ behavioral strategies:impact of phasing out subsidies for new energy vehicles［J］.Energy，2019，189:116064.
[17]Huang Y，Pu Y.Research on evolutionary game model of new energy vehicle timeshare rental market competition［J］.China Management Science，2018，26(2):79-85.
[18]Encarnao S，Santos F P，Santos F C，et al.Paths to the adoption of electric vehicles:an evolutionary game theoretical approach ［J］.Transportation Research Part B:Methodological，2018，113:24-33.
[19]Zhu J，Hu K，Lu X，et al.A review of geothermal energy resources，development，and applications in China:current status and prospects ［J］.Energy，2015，93:466-483.
[20]Zhang D，Zhang B，Zheng Y，et al.Economic assessment and regional adaptability analysis of CCHP system coupled with biomass-gas based on year-round performance ［J］.Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments，2021，45:101141.
[21]Geng Y，Wang X B，Zhang Q H，et al.Regional initiatives on promoting cleaner production in China:a case of Liaoning ［J］.Journal of Cleaner Production，2010，18(15):1502-1508.
[22]Ran R.Perverse incentive structure and policy implementation gap in China′s local environmental politics ［J］.Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning，2013，15(1):17-39.
[23]Li H，Zhu X，Chen J，et al.Environmental regulations，environmental governance efficiency and the green transformation of China′s iron and steel enterprises ［J］.Ecological Economics，2019，165:106397.
[24]Vardhan K H，Kumar P S，Panda R C.A review on heavy metal pollution，toxicity and remedial measures:current trends and future perspectives ［J］.Journal of Molecular Liquids，2019，290:111197.
[25]Lemmens S，Lecompte S.Case study of an organic Rankine cycle applied for excess heat recovery:technical，economic and policy matters ［J］.Energy Conversion and Management，2017，138:670-685.
[26]Tchanche B F，Lambrinos G，Frangoudakis A，et al.Low-grade heat conversion into power using organic Rankine cycles—a review of various applications ［J］.Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews，2011，15(8):3963-3979.
[27]Weibull J W.Evolutionary game theory［M］.London:MIT Press，1997.
[28]Friedman D.Evolutionary games in economics ［J］.Econometrica:Journal of the Econometric Society，1991，59(3):637-666.
[29]Lu Q，Sun Y，Mei S.Nonlinear control systems and power system dynamics ［M］.Berlin:Springer Science & Business Media，2001.
[30]张美琼，何军，马蕊燕，等.炼油厂利用低温余热进行有机朗肯循环发电及其效益分析［J］.石油炼制与化工，2020，51(12):92.(Zhang Mei-qiong，He Jun，Ma Rui-yan，et al.Organic rankine cycle power generation using low temperature waste heat in refinery and its benefit analysis ［J］.Petroleum Processing and Petrochemicals，2020，51(12):92.)［31］唐山市生态环境局.唐山市生态环境局挥发性有机物自动监测设备公开招标公告［EB/OL］.(2020-12-30)［2021-09-09］.http://www.ccgp.gov.cn/cggg/dfgg/gkzb/202012/t20201230_15725658.htm.(Tangshan Ecological Environment Bureau.Volatile organic compounds automatic monitoring equipment public tender notice in Tangshan Ecological Environment Bureau ［EB/OL］.(2020-12-30)［2021-09-09］.http://www.ccgp.gov.cn/cggg/dfgg/gkzb/202012/t20201230_157 25658.htm.)［32］唐山市生态环境局.唐山市建成区25公里范围内重点污染源安装监控设施和质控监测装置项目［EB/OL］.(2020-12-16)［2021-09-09］.http://ggzy.hebei.gov.cn/hbggfwpt/ jydt/003001/003001001/003001001005/20201216/ afe77905-ff37-4743-8509-a5a4e600c5ea.html.(Tangshan Ecological Environment Bureau.The installation of monitoring facilities and quality control monitoring devices for key pollution sources within 25km of the built-up area in Tangshan City ［EB/OL］.(2020-12-16)［2021-09-09］.http://ggzy.hebei.gov.cn/hbggfwpt/jydt/003001/003001001/003001001005/20201216/afe77905-ff37-4743-8509-a5a4e600c5ea.html.)［33］唐建勋，李雨珊.我市曝光11起重点环境违法行为［N/OL］.唐山劳动日报，2021-03-13［2021-09-09］.https://epaper.huanbohainews.com.cn/tsldrb/pc/content/202103/13/content_1698.html.(Tang Jian-xun，Li Yu-shan.The city exposed 11 key environmental violations ［N/OL］.Tangshan Labor Daily，2021-03-13［2021-09-09］.https://epaper.huanbohainews.com.cn/tsldrb/pc/content/202103/13/content_1698.html.)［34］河北省政府办公厅.支持重点行业和重点设施超低排放改造(深度治理)的若干措施(［2020］81号)［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.http://info.hebei.gov.cn//hbszfxxgk/6806024/6807473/6807180/6904218/6904253/6927668/index.html.)(General Office of Hebei Provincial Government.Several measures to support ultra-low emission transformation (deep treatment) in key industries and key facilities (［2020］No.81)［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.http://info.hebei.gov.cn//hbszfxxgk/6806024/6807473/6807180/6904218/69042 53/6927668/index.html.)［35］河北省工业和信息化厅.2020年度河北省工业转型升级(技改)重点项目建设专项资金申报指南［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.http://gxt.hebei.gov.cn/hbgyhxxht/xwzx32/tzgg83/659166/index.html.(Hebei Industry and Information Technology Department.Special funds for the construction of key projects for industrial transformation and upgrading(technological reform) in Hebei Province in 2020［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.http://gxt.hebei.gov.cn/hbgyhxxht/xwzx32/tzgg83/659166/index.html.)［36］隗斌贤，范丽娟，季宏.如何正确考评地方政府的政绩［J］.统计与决策，2006(16):39-41.(Kui Bin-xian，Fan Li-juan，Ji Hong.How to properly evaluate the performance of local governments［J］.Statistics & Decision，2006(16):39-41.)［37］中共唐山市委.唐山市市委管理的领导班子和干部综合考评［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.https://www.renrendoc.com/paper/155670840.html.(The Communist Party of China in Tangshan City.Comprehensive appraisal of leading teams and cadres managed by the Tangshan Municipal Committee ［EB/OL］.［2021-09-09］.https://www.renrendoc.com/paper/155670840.html.)