东北大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2025, Vol. 27 ›› Issue (3): 106-114.DOI: 10.15936/j.cnki.1008-3758.2025.03.012

• 法学研究 • 上一篇    

我国操纵证券市场民事赔偿诉讼中因果关系问题的类型化分析

范正阳   

  1. 北京大学 法学院,北京 100871
  • 收稿日期:2024-03-28 出版日期:2025-05-25 发布日期:2025-06-17
  • 作者简介:范正阳,北京大学博士研究生。

Typological Analysis of Causation Issues in Civil Compensation Litigation for Market Manipulation in China’s Securities Market

Zhengyang FAN   

  1. Law School,Peking University,Beijing 100871,China
  • Received:2024-03-28 Online:2025-05-25 Published:2025-06-17

摘要:

相较于行政处罚的频繁适用,作为受损害投资者获赔的主要路径,我国操纵证券市场民事赔偿诉讼曾长期处于形同虚设的状态。造成这种局面的主要原因在于,联结操纵行为与损害结果之间的因果关系要素在讼诉过程中难以认定。操纵市场这一概念充斥着根据不同分类标准发展而来的众多样态。在民事赔偿诉讼背景下,真正有意义的类型划分应当基于因果关系问题的不同处理方式而建立。根据操纵行为对投资者的投资决策和所受损失的影响方式,以交易型操纵和信息型操纵为界进行分类是较为合理的安排。在交易型操纵中,应当根据交易因果关系和损失因果关系实际成立的时点,合理地区分交易价格操纵和交易量操纵两种类型。在信息型操纵中,首先应当明晰信息型操纵的基本内涵,再根据其行为所具有的本质特征处理因果关系问题。

关键词: 操纵市场, 民事诉讼, 因果关系, 交易型操纵, 信息型操纵

Abstract:

Compared with the frequent application of administrative penalties, civil compensation litigation for manipulating the securities market has been in a state of virtual absence for a long time. The main reason for this situation is that the causal relationship between manipulative behaviors and damage results is difficult to determine in the judicial proceedings. The concept of market manipulation is replete with numerous forms developed based on different classification criteria. A meaningful typology should be established according to the different approaches to the causation issue. This should depend on the way in which manipulative behaviors affect investors’ investment decisions and losses. It is a reasonable arrangement to classify and discuss the categorization in terms of trade-based manipulation and information-based manipulation. In the trade-based manipulation, price manipulation and volume manipulation should be reasonably distinguished based on the actual time point when the causal relationship between the transaction and the loss is established. In the information-based manipulation, the basic connotation should be clarified first, and then the causal relationship issues should be addressed according to the essential characteristics of its behavior.

Key words: market manipulation, civil litigation, causation, trade-based manipulation, information-based manipulation

中图分类号: