东北大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2024, Vol. 26 ›› Issue (2): 92-101.DOI: 10.15936/j.cnki.1008-3758.2024.02.010

• 法学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

民事合同效力先决案件的诉讼形态

冯祝恒   

  1. (清华大学法学院,北京100084)
  • 发布日期:2024-04-07
  • 通讯作者: 冯祝恒
  • 作者简介:冯祝恒(1994-),男,山东临朐人,清华大学博士研究生,主要从事民事实体法与程序法协同实施研究。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金重大资助项目(22&ZD206);清华大学自主科研计划资助项目(2022THZWJC02)。

On the Litigation Form of Civil Contract Validity Precedent Cases

FENG Zhuheng   

  1. (School of Law, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China)
  • Published:2024-04-07
  • Contact: -
  • About author:-
  • Supported by:
    -

摘要: 民事合同效力先决案件的圆满解决需要探求其特定的诉讼形态。合同效力作为实体性先决问题具有“偏本土性”,其在我国民事程序中有着独特的角色承担。合同效力先决案件的传统处置,是根据合同效力之程序角色对应采取不同方式。当前,既判力客观范围的肆意扩张与诉之合并形态的疏漏,是传统处置模式积弊丛生的主要根源。对此,将既判力的客观范围拉回至“诉讼标的—既判力”的认同之下,在对合同效力作“诉讼标的化”改造的同时,进一步根据实体法权利体系明确完整的诉之合并形态,是一条较为可取的模式重构之路。由此呈现的合同效力先决案件之合理诉讼形态,即是一个确认之诉与两个真正的预备合并之诉的搭配组合。这一诉讼形态本质上乃诉的合并制度的功能发挥,是对现有诉讼制度的“挖潜”。

关键词: 合同效力先决案件; 诉讼形态; 既判力; 确认之诉; 诉的合并

Abstract: The successful settlement of civil contract validity precedent cases needs to explore its specific litigation form. Contract validity as a substantive precedent issue is “slightly local” and plays a unique role in China's civil procedure. Traditionally, the handling of contract validity precedent cases was done in different ways according to the procedural role of contract validity. At present, the arbitrary expansion of the objective scope of the res judicata and the omission of the combined form of the lawsuit, are the main sources of the problems of the traditional handling mode. In this regard, there is a better way to do paradigm reconstruction: pull the objective scope of the res judicata back to the identity of “the object of action-res judicata”, and further determine the complete combined form of the lawsuit according to the substantive law rights system while transforming the contract effect into the object of action. This presents the reasonable litigation form of contract validity precedent cases—combining the lawsuit of affirmation and two real lawsuits of preparatory consolidation. Naturally, this kind of litigation form realizes the function of the consolidation of the lawsuit, and it is the “trapping potential” of the existing litigation system.

Key words: contract validity precedent case; litigation form; res judicata; lawsuit of affirmation; consolidation of the lawsuit

中图分类号: