陶瓷细骨料替代方式对混凝土抗压强度的影响

doi:10.12068/j.issn.1005-3026.2020.11.022

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 为了提高废弃陶瓷在混凝土中的利用率，将废弃陶瓷破碎、筛分加工成人工细骨料，按不同比例(10%，20%，30%，40%及50%)，且分别采用“C”替代法(即传统替代方式，要求陶瓷细骨料细度模数与天然河砂细度模数相近即可，等质量取代)、“P”替代法(陶瓷细骨料一对一平均替代对应的不同粒径的天然河砂)、“D”替代法(陶瓷细骨料一对一且仅替代粒径为1.18，2.36和4.75mm粒径相对较大的天然河砂)及“X”替代法(陶瓷细骨料一对一且仅替代粒径为0.15，0.3和0.6mm粒径相对较小的天然河砂)取代天然河砂，制备陶瓷细骨料混凝土.共设计21组混凝土，包括基准混凝土1组，“C”，“P”，“D”及“X”替代法各5组.水胶比均为0.49，进行混凝土28d的抗压强度试验.结果表明:在水胶比为0.49的条件下，陶瓷细骨料掺量不大于50%时，陶瓷细骨料混凝土抗压强度和基准混凝土为同一强度等级，均到达C30强度等级要求；不同的替代方式，对应的陶瓷细骨料最佳掺量不同；不同的陶瓷细骨料掺量，对应的最优替代方式不同.

关键词: 废弃陶瓷, 细骨料, 替代方式, 混凝土, 抗压强度

Abstract: In order to improve the utilization rate of waste ceramics in concrete， ceramic concrete was prepared by using “C” substitution method (traditional equal mass substitution method)，“P” substitution method (substitute natural river sands with different particle sizes)， “D” substitution method (substitute natural river sands with particle sizes of 1.18， 2.36 and 4.75mm) and “X” substitution method (substitute natural river sands with particle sizes of 0.15， 0.3 and 0.6mm.) to replace natural fine aggregate according to different proportion (10%， 20%， 30%， 40%， 50%). 21 groups of concrete were designed， including 1 group of reference concrete， 5 groups of concrete prepared of “C”， “P”， “D” and “X” substitution method respectively. The water-binder ratio is 0.49， and the compressive strength test of concrete takes for 28 days. The results show that when the water-binder ratio is 0.49 and the ceramic fine aggregate content is less than 50%， the compressive strength of ceramic fine aggregate concrete and the reference concrete are of the same strength level， and all reach the strength level of C30. The optimal substitution rate is different for different ceramic fine aggregate substitution methods. Different substitution rates of ceramic fine aggregate correspond to different optimal substitution methods.

Key words: waste ceramics, fine aggregate, substitute mode, concrete, compressive strength

中图分类号:

TU528.041

程云虹，杨四辉，张靖瑜，童柏强. 陶瓷细骨料替代方式对混凝土抗压强度的影响[J]. 东北大学学报:自然科学版, 2020, 41(11): 1661-1666.

CHENG Yun-hong， YANG Si-hui， ZHANG Jing-yu， TONG Bai-qiang. Effect of Substitution of Ceramic Fine Aggregate on Compressive Strength of Concrete[J]. Journal of Northeastern University Natural Science, 2020, 41(11): 1661-1666.

参考文献

[1]吴中伟，廉慧珍.高性能混凝土［M］.北京:中国铁道出版社，1999:1-2.(Wu Zhong-wei，Lian Hui-zhen.High performance concrete［M］.Beijing:China Railway Press，1999:1-2.)
[2]王长远，王功勋，裴启文，等.全组分利用废瓷砖制备混凝土及其耐久性［J］.混凝土，2017，39(11):181-184.(Wang Chang-yuan，Wang Gong-xun，Pei Qi-wen，et al.Concrete prepared by waste tile and its durability［J］.Concrete，2017，39(11):181-184.)
[3]刘凤利，张承志，刘俊华.利用废陶瓷再生粗砂配制再生砂浆的试验研究［J］.河南大学学报(自然科学版)，2011，41(4):425-428.(Liu Feng-li，Zhang Cheng-zhi，Liu Jun-hua.Experimental study on preparation of recycled mortar from waste ceramic recycled coarse sand［J］.Journal of Henan University (Natural Science Edition)，2011，41 (4):425-428.)
[4]毋雪梅，李愿，管宗甫.废弃陶瓷再生混凝土及界面研究［J］.郑州大学学报(工学版)，2010，31(2):38-41.(Wu Xue-mei，Li Yuan，Guan Zong-fu.Study on recycled concrete and interface of waste ceramics［J］.Journal of Zhengzhou University (Engineering Edition)，2010，31 (2):38-41.)
[5]陆盛武，曾志兴.陶瓷细骨料再生混凝土抗压强度试验研究［J］.混凝土，2013，35(4):62-66.(Lu Sheng-wu，Zeng Zhi-xing.Experimental study on compressive strength of recycled concrete with ceramic fine aggregate［J］.Concrete，2013，35(4):62-66.)
[6]Awoyera P O，Ndambuki J M，Akinmusuru J O，et al.Characterization of ceramic waste aggregate concrete［J］.HBRC Journal，2018，14(3):282-287.
[7]Siddigue S，Shrivastava S，Chaudhary S，et al.Strength and impact resistance properties of concrete containing fine bone china ceramic aggregate［J］.Construction and Building Materials，2018，169(30):289-298.
[8]Siddique S，Shrivastava S，Chaudhary S.Evaluating resistance of fine bone china ceramic aggregate concrete to sulphate attack［J］.Construction and Building Materials，2018，186(20):826-832.
[9]Siddique S，Shrivastava S，Chaudhary S.Influence of ceramic waste as fine aggregate in concrete:pozzolanic，XRD，FT-IR，and NMR investigations［J］.Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering，2018，30(9):04018227.
[10]Siddique S，Chaudhary S，Shrivastava S，et al.Sustainable utilisation of ceramic waste in concrete:exposure to adverse conditions［J］.Journal of Cleaner Production，2019，210(10):246-255.
[11]Stanislav S，Miarka P，Jacek D，et al.Change of a crack propagation rate in fine-grained cement-based composites due to partial replacement of aggregate by ceramic waste［J］.Key Engineering Materials，2018，761:111-115.
[12]Etxeberria M，Vegas I.Effect of fine ceramic recycled aggregate (RA) and mixed fine RA on hardened properties of concrete［J］.Magazine of Concrete Research，2015，67(11/12):645-655.
[13]Siddique S，Shrivastava S，Chaudhary S.Influence of ceramic waste on the fresh properties and compressive strength of concrete［J］.European Journal of Environmental and Civil Engineering，2019，23(2):212-225.
[14]Halicka A，Ogrodnik P，Zegardlo B.Using ceramic sanitary ware waste as concrete aggregate［J］.Construction and Building Materials，2013，48(11):295-305.
[15]Etxeberria M，Gonzalez-Corominas A.The assessment of ceramic and mixed recycled aggregates for high strength and low shrinkage concretes［J］.Materials and Structures，2018，51(5):129-150.
[16]Higashiyama H，Yagishita F，Sano M，et al.Compressive strength and resistance to chloride penetration of mortars using ceramic waste as fine aggregate［J］.Construction and Building Materials，2012，26(1):96-101.
[17]Torkittikul P，Chaipanich A.Utilization of ceramic waste as fine aggregate within Portland cement and fly ash concretes［J］.Cement & Concrete Composites，2010，32(6):440-449.
[15]关守平，房少纯.一种新型的区间-粒子群优化算法［J］.东北大学学报(自然科学版)，2012，33(10):1381-1384.(Guan Shou-ping，Fang Shao-chun.A new interval particle swarm optimization algorithm［J］.Journal of Northeastern University(Natural Science)，2012，33(10):1381-1384.)(上接第1652页)
[9]Babuka I，Melenk J M.The partition of unity method［J］.International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering，1997，40(4):727-758.
[10]Tian R，Yagawa G，Terasaka H.Linear dependence problems of partition of unity-based generalized FEMs［J］.Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering，2005，195(37):4768-4782.
[11]Béchet E，Minnebo H，Mos N，et al.Improved implementation and robustness study of the X-FEM for stress analysis around cracks［J］.International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering，2005，64(1):1033-1056.
[12]Laborde P，Pommier J，Renard Y，et al.High-order extended finite element method for cracked domains［J］.International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering，2005，64(1):354-381.
[13]王理想，文龙飞，王景焘，等.基于改进型XFEM的裂纹分析并行软件实现［J］.中国科学(技术科学)，2018，48(11):1241-1258.(Wang Lin-xiang，Wen Long-fei，Wang Jing-tao，et al.Implementations of parallel software for crack analyses based on the improved XFEM［J］.Scientia Sinica(Technologica)，2018，48(11):1241-1258.)
[14]Wu J，Li F.An improved stable XFEM (Is-XFEM) with a novel enrichment function for the computational modeling of cohesive cracks［J］.Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering，2015，295:77-107.
[15]庄茁.拓展有限单元法［M］.北京:清华大学出版社，2012:44-45.(Zhuang Zhuo.Extended finite element method［M］.Beijing:Tsinghua University Press，2012:44-45.)
[16]Agarwal P K，Ben A R，Kaplan H，et al.Computing the discrete Frechet distance in subquadratic time［J］.SIAM Journal on Computing，2014，43(2):429-449.
[17]Dolbow J E.An extended finite element method with discontinuous enrichment for applied mechanics［D］.Evanston:Northwestern University，1999.
[18]王青原，陈红鸟，张华刚，等.三点弯曲下混凝土梁挠度与裂缝口张开位移关系［J］.应用力学学报，2017，34(5):937-943.(Wang Qing-yuan，Chen Hong-niao，Zhang Hua-gang，et al.Relationship of deflection and crack mouth opening displacement of concrete beams under the three-point bending［J］.Chinese Journal of Applied Mechanics，2017，34(5):937-943.)
[19]唐宇翔，陈红鸟，王青原，等.基于扩展有限元法的混凝土断裂参数研究［J］.应用力学报，2019，36(6):1-7.(Tang Yu-xiang，Chen Hong-niao，Wang Qing-yuan，et al.Research on fracture parameters of concrete based on extended finite element method［J］.Chinese Journal of Applied Mechanics，2019，36(6):1-7.)