Multi-objective Decision-Making Method for Bridge Deck Maintenance Scheme for Highway

doi:10.12068/j.issn.1005-3026.2020.07.019

Abstract

Abstract: In view of the low efficiency of bridge maintenance decision-making， insufficient maintenance funds and unreasonable fund allocation， a multi-objective decision-making method for bridge deck maintenance scheme of highway was proposed. Firstly， a database was established to collect quantitative data of maintenance methods. Secondly， entropy-weight TOPSIS and analytic hierarchy process (AHP) were used to determine the maintenance priority coefficients of bridge decks in highway networks and the weights of maintenance objectives respectively. Thirdly， a multi-objective decision-making model based on 0-1 knapsack problems was established. Finally， five bridges on Raocheng Highway (G1501) located in Shenyang city in Liaoning Province， China were taken as a case study to demonstrate the validity and the effectiveness of the proposed method. The results showed that the proposed method considers the maintenance priorities of bridge decks during the maintenance decision-making process and can give reasonable and feasible maintenance solutions， thus it can be an effective support for the maintenance decision-making management of highway bridges.

Key words: bridge maintenance management, TOPSIS, analytic hierarchy process(AHP), 0-1 knapsack problem, multi-objective optimization

CLC Number:

TP20

QI Xi-jing， TANG Liang， KANG Wei-xin， QIN Jiao-jiao. Multi-objective Decision-Making Method for Bridge Deck Maintenance Scheme for Highway[J]. Journal of Northeastern University Natural Science, 2020, 41(7): 1033-1040.

References

[1]Yoon Y，Hastak M.Multitiered prioritizing method using urgency scale for bridge deck rehabilitation［J］.Journal of Infrastructure Systems，2017，23(4):04017020.
[2]Ferhat A.Bridge management in Turkey:a BMS design with customised functionalities［J］.Structure and Infrastructure Engineering，2016，12(5):647-666.
[3]Razaqpur A G，Halim A O A E，Mohamed H A.Bridge management by dynamic programming and neural networks［J］.Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering，1996，23(5):1064-1069.
[4]Lee C K，Kim S K.GA-based algorithm for selecting optimal repair and rehabilitation methods for reinforced concrete (RC) bridge decks［J］.Automation in Construction，2007，16(2):153-164.
[5]Zoubir L，Lyne D.Multi-objective and probabilistic decision-making approaches to sustainable design and management of highway bridge decks［J］.Structure and Infrastructure Engineering，2013，9(4):364-383.
[6]Shim H S，Lee S H，Kang B S.Pareto front generation for bridge deck management system using bi-objective optimization［J］.KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering，2017，21(5):1563-1572.
[7]Shim H S，Lee S H.Balanced allocation of bridge deck maintenance budget through multi-objective optimization［J］.KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering，2017，21(4):1039-1046.
[8]Yadollahi M，Majid M Z A，Zin R M.Post-Pareto optimality approach to enhance budget allocation process for bridge rehabilitation management［J］.Structure and Infrastructure Engineering，2015，11(12):1565-1582.
[9]交通运输部公路科学研究院.公路桥梁技术状况评定标准:JTG/T H21—2011［S］.北京:人民交通出版社，2011.(Research Institute of Highway Ministry of Transport.Standards for technical condition evaluation of highway bridge:JTG/T H21—2011［S］.Beijing:China Communications Press Co.，Ltd.，2011.)
[10]Neves L A C，Frangopol D M.Probabilistic lifetime-oriented multiobjective pptimization of bridge maintenance:combination of maintenance types［J］.Journal of Structural Engineering，2006，132(6):991-1005.
[11]Ghodoosi F，Abu-Samra S，Zeynalian M，et al.Maintenance cost optimization for bridge structures using system reliability analysis and genetic algorithms［J］.Journal of Construction Engineering and Management，2018，144(2):04017116.
[12]Liu C L，Hammad A，Itoh Y.Maintenance strategy optimization of bridge decks using genetic algorithm［J］.Journal of Transportation Engineering，1997，123(2):91-100.
[13]Chen T Y.A novel PROMETHEE-based method using a Pythagorean fuzzy combinative distance-based precedence approach to multiple criteria decision making［J］.Applied Soft Computing，2019，82:105560.
[14]Lee S Y，Park W，Ok S Y，et al.Preference-based maintenance planning for deteriorating bridges under multi-objective optimization framework［J］.Structure and Infrastructure Engineering，2011，7(7/8):633-644.
[15]王述红，张泽，侯文帅，等.综合管廊多灾种耦合致灾风险评价方法［J］.东北大学学报(自然科学版)，2018，39(6):902-906.(Wang Shu-hong，Zhang Ze，Hou Wen-shuai，et al.Risk assessment method on multi-disaster coupled hazard for urban utility tunnel［J］.Journal of Northeastern University(Natural Science)，2018，39(6):902-906.)
[16]Silvano M，David P，Paolo T.New trends in exact algorithms for the 0-1 knapsack problem［J］.European Journal of Operational Research，2000，123(2):325-332.
[15]关守平，房少纯.一种新型的区间-粒子群优化算法［J］.东北大学学报(自然科学版)，2012，33(10):1381-1384.(Guan Shou-ping，Fang Shao-chun.A new interval particle swarm optimization algorithm［J］.Journal of Northeastern University(Natural Science)，2012，33(10):1381-1384.)(上接第1013页)
[4]Feng Q，Zhao W，Wen S.Ammonia modification for enhancing adsorption of sulfide species onto malachite surfaces and implications for flotation［J］.Journal of Alloys & Compounds，2018，744:301-309.
[5]Wu D，Ma W，Mao Y，et al.Enhanced sulfidation xanthate flotation of malachite using ammonium ions as activator［J］.Scientific Reports，2017，7(1):1-9.
[6]杨磊，孙建伟.低品位氧化蓝铜矿硫化浮选试验研究［J］.新疆有色金属，2009，32(sup2):100-102.(Yang Lei，Sun Jian-wei.Experimental study on sulfide flotation of low-grade oxidized azurite ore［J］.Xinjiang Youse Jinshu，2009，32(sup2) :100-102.)
[7]Srdjan M B.Handbook of flotation reagents:chemistry，theory and practice:flotation of gold，PGM and oxide minerals［M］.Amsterdam:Elsevier Science，2010:47-50.
[8]Pearse M J.An overview of the use of chemical reagents in mineral processing［J］.Minerals Engineering，2005，18(2):139-149.
[9]蒋太国，方建军，毛莹博，等.铵(胺)盐对孔雀石硫化浮选行为的影响［J］.矿产保护与利用，2015(4):31-37.(Jiang Tai-guo，Fang Jian-jun，Mao Ying-bo，et al.Impact of ammonium(amine) salt on behavior of malachite sulfide flotation［J］.Conservation and Utilization of Mineral Resources，2015(4):31-37.)
[10]Yang X F，Liu Q J，Deng R D .Flotation of copper oxide minerals using ethylene phosphate as activators［J］.Advanced Materials Research，2012，581/582:975-982.
[11] 蒋太国，方建军，张铁民，等.铵(胺)盐对氧化铜矿硫化浮选行为的影响［J］.矿产保护与利用，2014(1):15-20.(Jiang Tai-guo，Fang Jian-jun，Zhang Tie-min，et al.Impact of ammonium(amine) salt on the sulfide flotation behavior of oxidized copper ores［J］.Conservation and Utilization of Mineral Resources，2014(1):15-20.)
[12]Wang Y J，Wen S M，Liu D，et al.Recovery copper from a complex copper sulfide ore of Yunnan by using flotation［J］.Applied Mechanics and Materials，2015，737:839-842.
[13] Wen Y，Fang J J，Mao Y B，et al.Flotation of a refractory copper oxide ore using ammonium bicarbonate as activator［J］.Advanced Materials Research，2012，581/582:969-974.
[14] Corin K C，Kalichini M，O’Connor C T，et al.The recovery of oxide copper minerals from a complex copper ore by sulphidisation［J］.Minerals Engineering，2017，102:15-17.
[15] Wen S M，Deng J S，Xian Y J，et al.Theory analysis and vestigial information of surface relaxation of natural chalcopyrite mineral crystal［J］.Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China，2013，23(3):796-803.
[15]关守平，房少纯.一种新型的区间-粒子群优化算法［J］.东北大学学报(自然科学版)，2012，33(10):1381-1384.(Guan Shou-ping，Fang Shao-chun.A new interval particle swarm optimization algorithm［J］.Journal of Northeastern University(Natural Science)，2012，33(10):1381-1384.)