东北大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2017, Vol. 19 ›› Issue (4): 405-410.DOI: 10.15936/j.cnki.1008-3758.2017.04.012

• 法学研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

论以房抵债协议买卖条款之法律效力——以民间借贷司法解释第24条为中心

裴亚洲,单星辰   

  1. (北京化工大学文法学院,北京100029)
  • 收稿日期:2016-12-10 修回日期:2016-12-10 出版日期:2017-07-25 发布日期:2017-07-20
  • 通讯作者: 裴亚洲
  • 作者简介:裴亚洲(1973-),男,河北沧州人,北京化工大学副教授,主要从事民商法研究。

Effectiveness of the Sale-on Terms in Housing-debt Contract ——Focus on Private Lending Judicial Explanation for Article 24

PEI Ya-zhou, SHAN Xing-chen   

  1. (School of Arts and Law, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing 100029, China)
  • Received:2016-12-10 Revised:2016-12-10 Online:2017-07-25 Published:2017-07-20
  • Contact: -
  • About author:-
  • Supported by:
    -

摘要: 以房抵债协议是指通过签订房屋买卖合同担保民间借贷的协议,其在司法实践中大量存在,对于该协议中买卖条款的效力的认定存在有效与无效的争议,而《最高人民法院关于审理民间借贷案件适用法律若干问题的规定》第24条则对其效力采取了回避的态度。因为以房抵债协议不存在通谋虚伪意思表示且与流押契约有明显区别,因此不能直接对其买卖条款的效力进行否定。通过对以房抵债协议买卖条款的性质进行剖析,对让与担保说、后让与担保说、附解除条件的合同说提出质疑,指出其本质上属于代物清偿预约,在符合法定情形下,债权人可以排除第三人对房屋价款的请求权,即债权人此时享有物权期待权,以期对司法实践中此类争议的解决提供一个可以参考的路径。

关键词: 以房抵债协议, 买卖条款, 民间借贷合同 , 代物清偿预约

Abstract: A housing-debt contract is an agreement to guarantee private lending through signing a house sale and purchase contract. Despite its enormous practices, there is still dispute on the effectiveness and ineffectivenessin terms of the clause validity. What is worse, Article 24 of “The provisions of the supreme people’s court on the application of law in private lending cases”adopts an avoidance attitude towards this issue. The validity of house-debtcontracts could not be denied simply because there is no false intention or conspiracy, which is different from fluidity contracts. By analyzing the nature of the clauses for house-debt contracts, such explanations as alienation guarantee, after-alienation guarantee, contract with termination and conditional sale contract are questionable. A house-debt contract is essentially a pre-contract for datio in solutum,and in accordance with the legal cases, the creditors can rule out the third person's claim for the housing price, i.e., the creditor shall enjoy the right of property expectation, which may provide useful reference for setting such disputes in judicial practices.

Key words: housing-debt contract, sale-on term, loan contract, pre-contract for datio in solutum

中图分类号: